Skip to content

Insight

What an AI visibility check actually measures.

Explanatory graphic: four separate measurement fields with individual markers; open connections do not represent measured values.
AI illustration
Published

In short · 3 min read

  • A source review, not measured client impact.
  • Keep mentions, citations, visits and enquiries separate.
  • Provider reports each cover a limited scope.

Our question and method

What has actually been demonstrated when a report claims “more AI visibility”? On 19 November 2026, we compared public documentation from Google, Microsoft and OpenAI, looking for metric definitions, scope and limits.

  • Method: Open official pages and compare the terms used.
  • Material: Public search requirements and reporting definitions.
  • Boundary: No series of model queries, client data or measured commercial outcome.

Four outcomes to keep separate

This is our interpretation framework, not a shared provider standard:

Observation What it establishes What it does not establish
Mention A name appears in a saved response That your website supplied the evidence
Citation A response links to a particular page That anyone clicked the link
Visit A measured page view was attributed to a source That a relevant enquiry followed
Enquiry A genuine contact was recorded That one AI response alone caused it

Our conclusion: a report should always identify the outcome it observed. Otherwise, a change is difficult to interpret.

AI illustration: a person compares an illustrative AI answer on a laptop with a highlighted source passage on a tablet.
AI illustration: distinguishing a mention from its source. The scene shows source checking, not measured visibility.

What the providers document

Microsoft’s AI Visibility Insights announcement describes the preview metric Citation Share. Microsoft identifies it as an observational measure, not a ranking system or traffic share. We therefore do not treat it as market share across every AI service.

Google’s source dates matter. Its AI search documentation describes AI search traffic within Web performance reporting. A newer official post describes additional AI appearance insights; an update reports worldwide rollout by 31 August 2026. A blanket claim that Google offers no AI insights would be too broad. Actual data for a particular site still needs to be checked in its account.

OpenAI documents search and training crawlers separately. This explains access, but does not itself demonstrate a mention. Technical permission and an observed response are different outcomes.

How we would structure a sample

Our working proposal from this research:

  1. Choose questions in advance. Use real audience needs, not selected positive results.
  2. Record context. Service, language, time and available usage-context information.
  3. Save complete answers. Include citations and qualifications.
  4. Compare outcomes separately. Record missing mentions too; measure visits and contacts separately.
  5. Log changes. A different page, service or context limits comparison.
AI illustration: a laptop displays an example article beside a phone showing an unfilled contact form.
AI illustration: a page visit is not yet an inquiry. Reading and getting in touch are distinct observable steps.

Limits of this research

This is an interpretation of public provider documentation. We did not independently validate reporting systems or measure a site’s visibility. The proposed sample is not a completed study.

  • Coverage: These services do not represent the entire market.
  • Time: Documentation and features may change after this date.
  • Impact: A change over time alone demonstrates neither causation nor revenue.

Your next step

Frequently asked questions.

Is Citation Share a market share?

Microsoft describes an observation within the covered citation context. It does not establish general market share or visitor share.

Did this research test a client’s visibility?

No. It compares public documentation, without collecting a client visibility dataset.

Why is a before-and-after screenshot insufficient?

It shows selected answers, not a comparable collection method. Questions, context, missing results and other changes also matter.

Sources.

  1. Google: AI features and your websiteVendor / primary · As of
  2. Google: New opportunities, control and insights; Nachtrag 31.08.2026Vendor / primary · As of
  3. Microsoft: New AI Visibility Insights, 16.06.2026Vendor / primary · As of
All 4 sources
  1. OpenAI: Overview of OpenAI CrawlersVendor / primary · As of